Maria Montez (not her real name) is a senior
citizen who stands for hours during her shift at a poultry
processing plant. In the damp and chill, she performs her
assigned task at breakneck speed as freshly-killed chickens,
hooked to a conveyor, speed past her.
She has done this repetitive work for years.
Now her hands and arms are often numb. Sometimes the pain
keeps her awake at night. She cannot afford to pay the insurance
deductible to see a doctor.
"A lot of people are also affected with
asthma and pneumonia and eye problems," Maria, a Latino,
says through a translator. "Thats what I see the
most. People have to leave the plant because of illness. People
get fired if they get hurt (on the job)."
Maria Montez is not alone. She is just one of
the many people whose story is included in the new pastoral
letter, Voices and Choices, released this past November
with the signatures of 41 Catholic bishops of the South.
The process leading to this pastoral was initiated
and facilitated by the Catholic Committee of the South (CCS),
a group that has received support from the Glenmary Commission
on Justice since the 1980s. Glenmary priests, brothers, coworkers
and parishioners are among the nearly 100 people from across
the South who regularly attend the CCS Annual Gathering in
Cullman, Ala.
Years of testimony from poultry growers and
processing workers at this annual meeting prepared the way
for this pastoral message from bishops in dioceses most affected
by the poultry industry. Over the last two years, additional
input was systematically gathered from hundreds of people
and more than a dozen organizationsfrom poultry workers
and managers to diocesan officials and bishops.
Voices and Choices details the high
"price" poultry processing workers, poultry catchers
and poultry growers pay so that U.S. consumers might enjoy
plentiful and inexpensive poultry. That "price"
includes serious injuries, disabling repetitive-motion trauma,
disrespectful treatment and inadequate pay.
While the document is specific to the poultry
industry, the issues raised apply to many businesses, including
manufacturing and agriculture in general. The bishops hope
this document will raise awareness of injustice in our complex,
global economy.
Scripture, encyclicals and previous pastoral
documents are cited in Voices and Choices. These citations
highlight the necessity of recognizing the God-given dignity
of each person; the need for a safe and just workplace; the
special challenges of immigrant workers; and the essential
priority of shared responsibility and decision-makingthe
"voices and choices"in the workplace.
The right of Maria Montez and other poultry
workers to just employment is not based on the will of her
employer, this pastoral message emphasizes. It is grounded
in the reality that all are made in Gods image and likeness.
"We are called to recognize the divine
presence in each other, particularly those who are without
voices and choices in their lives," the bishops
say.
"We are called to continuous growth in
the awareness of Gods presence in our daily lives. Sometimes
the focus of this awareness is close at hand, such as our
families and friends; other times it is not so obvious, such
as those who work to supply the food we place on our table."
"This pastoral letter is about awareness,
not answers," the bishops continue. "It is about
our willingness to struggle with the questions of living as
children of God. It is about our willingness to open our minds
and hearts to Gods presence in people we may never meet,
but whose lives are as important as ours are in the sight
of God."
The bishops pastoral message is
published in Spanish and English in an effort to reach
out to immigrant workers affected by the issues explored in
the document. Like many Catholics who came to this country
in the past, present-day immigrants are vulnerable and often
desperate for work. They rarely seek help from authorities
when mistreated. These brothers and sisters need special consideration,
according to the bishops.
"While the laws regarding immigration and
immigrants must be respected, everything must be done to aid
and protect this most vulnerable and exploitable group of
brothers and sisters, many of whom are fleeing civil conflicts
in Latin America which have included the United States as
a political player."
The bishops cite the story of the Good Samaritan
from Luke 10, concluding, "The injured traveler is treated
tenderly by one with whom he should not even speak, and provided
for until his recovery. Who was the neighbor? The young man
answers, The one who showed him mercy. Jesus said
to him, Go and do likewise.
"Doing likewise is usually
associated with soup kitchens and other important tasks of
charity," the bishops continue. "But the definition
of neighborliness extends not only beyond our family, friends
and faith community, but beyond traditional tasks of charity
as well, until our entire lives are an opportunity to live
the gospel."
Voices and Choices includes a summary
of 100 years of Catholic social teaching prepared by the United
States Catholic Conference in 1990. Summary headings include
"the life and dignity of the human person," "human
rights and responsibilities," "the call to family
and community," "the dignity and rights of workers,"
"the option for the poor," and "solidarity"
with all people. The summary ends with the statement, "Loving
our neighbor has global dimensions."
"Those dimensions have economics as an
essential component," the bishops say, "one that
can seem removed from our gospel vision of neighborliness."
Complicated concepts and unfamiliar terminologysuch
as "vertical integration"may further obscure
our vision. But the pastoral letter challenges us to confront
the complexity.
"Vertical integration, in which
the same company owns and/or controls every step of production
from the most basic components, such as feed grain, to the
final product, such as boneless, skinless chicken breasts
on the grocery store shelves, has become a dominant force
in the economy," the bishops explain. "The ramifications
are too numerous to treat here, but according to the National
Catholic Rural Life Conference, factory farming
impacts prices, wages, natural resources and the future of
family farming, placing enormous power in the boardrooms of
a few companies."
Voices and Choices notes that legal tasks
and structural change are necessary to address the intricate
and interconnected web of environmental, technological, political,
financial and international issues involved. Still, the bishops
say, "We may not abdicate our concern and responsibilities
for such matters to the anonymous group. The group
is made up of individuals. Structural change begins with the
conversion of each heart."
The bishops note that as "accountants,
nurses, managers, executives, politicians, teachers, voters,
consumers, bankers, bakers, mechanics, secretaries, parents
and clerks, we make decisions every day that affect the lives
of other people. We must struggle in holiness with the competing
values of the workplace, with the contradictory and complex
choices with which we are faced."
We must not be afraid of this daunting task,
the bishops say, because, as Pope John Paul II reminds us,
"Each and every human being has been created in the image
and likeness of the One who is the origin of all that is.
We have within us the capacities for wisdom and virtue.
"With these gifts, and with the help of
Gods grace, we can build in the next century and the
next millennium a civilization worthy of the human person,
a true culture of freedom."
Susan Stevenot Sullivan, working in close
association with Glenmary Father Les Schmidt, played a key
role in the researching, drafting and final presentation of
"Voices and Choices." Based in Atlanta, she is a
freelance writer who has worked for the Catholic Committee
of the South and Glenmary Home Missioners.